Sharing a bed is only natural for a couple, and so are individual preferences! A mattress is bit of an individual preference, and if you’re lucky your partner has the same idea of comfort. That is often rare — imagine being a light sleeper sharing a spring mattress with someone who tosses and turns through the night. One person compromising is not the best solution, when one can as easily look for best mattresses for couples with different preferences.
You can love the same TV shows, enjoy the same music, and love to spend time in each others’ company. But waking up tired everyday will take its toll on a relationship. While there are a lot of things a couple can (and should) compromise on, a mattress that makes you uncomfortable is perhaps not the thing to sidestep.
Best Mattresses for Couples With Different Preferences
1. Leesa Mattress, Queen, 10inch Cooling Avena and Contouring Memory Foam Mattress
Leesa is a well-known brand, and generally well liked for its high-quality products. It makes a great mattress for the average couple. It has great motion isolation so you won’t disturb your significant other every time you take a turn or check your phone, and the medium firmness means you’re not looking at something super plush or very hard.
Leesa’s own Avena memory foam layer handles the sleep-hot problem of memory foam fairly well, so won’t have to find cooling solutions for your tempurpedic mattress. The mattress has medium sinkage, so it pretty much covers sleeping styles ranging from on-the-back to stomach sleepers. The mattress tries to cater to every category, and unless you’re looking for something very specific, it should be a fit.
Of course, sleeping isn’t all that a couple is going to do on their bed, and memory foams are somewhat notorious for being too passive in this area. The mattress handles this problem by introducing a bounce that should make it more acceptable for when things heat up.
Price: $845
Highlights:
- Direct-to-Consumer mattress
- Three-layer mattress including Avena cooling foam comfort layer
- 100 night in-home free trial
- 10 Year Warranty
Pros:
- Direct to Consumer
- Suitable for most sleeping styles
- Has some bounce
Cons:
- Some risk of sleeping-hot
- Poor edge support
2. Helix Sleep Custom Mattress – 10 Inch
A customizable mattress can be a great choice for couples with different preferences. Helix caters to different tastes by offering customization of the mattress for each side of the bed. So if you prefer a firm bed while your partner is partial to a plush mattress, Helix will customize a mattress just for you.
If you don’t find a solution right out of the box, you can move to customizing the mattress. Each of you answers some questions for Helix, and the brand will either offer a custom blend of materials to best suit your requirements, or they will split the mattress into two, offering each side their preference.
Since most of the materials are custom-picked for the consumers, Helix employs microcoils in its construction. These help the mattress score great on motion isolation, and keep the door open in offering custom solutions for the support and comfort layers.
Price: $995 (dependent on customization)
Highlights:
- 100 night in-home free trial
- Customized to individual preferences
- 10-year warranty
- Microcoils for motion isolation
Pros:
- Customized to individual needs of the couple
- Good motion isolation
- Good bounce
Cons:
- Customization may reduce lifespan of the mattress
3. Kingsdown Passions Imagination Plush Mattress, Queen
Kingsdown takes a more homely approach to the mattress. The build works not just for the couple, but also thinks of kids crawling into bed with their parents, and pets wanting to join in on your slumber. The company encourages the purchase of a larger size mattress, not simply for catering to the different preferences of a couple, but also as a way to provide more room.
They use Tri-Zoned wrapped coils for motion isolation so you’d be comfortable even as your partner turns in bed at night, or if your pet decides to come in and sleep at your feet. The same coils are also claimed to provide targeted lumbar support for a more comfortable sleep. The innerspring mattress also offers foundations (sold separately) should you need to enhance the functions on offer.
Price: $836
Highlights:
- Excellent edge support
- 10 Year Warranty
- Innerspring mattress
Pros:
- Good motion isolation
- Good lumbar support
- Good edge support
Cons:
- Many reviews say the mattress does not perform well after three years
4. LINENSPA 10 Inch Latex Hybrid Mattress – Supportive – Responsive Feel – Medium Firm
Linenspa’s mattress is a no-frills fit for those on a budget. Don’t let the price fool you though, this one doesn’t sacrifice quality to get you a good price, and it has a CertiPUR-US certification to prove that. This hybrid mattress has four layers of foam and latex, with latex at the top keeping your bed temperature neutral.
A layer of gel memory foam further helps keep the mattress stay temperature neutral, and finally it’s down to individually encased coils to provide the mattress with bounce, flexibility, and breathability of innerspring (we have previously explained the dynamics of memory foam vs hybrid mattresses).
Price: $299.99
Highlights:
- Hybrid mattress with Latex, memory foam and innerspring
- 10-year warranty
- Excellent budget option
Pros:
- Hybrid mattress with good edge support and bounce
- Affordable price
Cons:
- Can sleep-hot
5. NECTAR Queen Mattress – Gel Memory Foam
Nectar has formed the match for different preferences in a mattress that’s both plush and firm, making it a choice for a couple shopping for a mattress. Plus, it offers great value, so you gotta love it even more. The mattress has deep contours and a plush feel, plus, it lets even the lighter part (not just the pressure points) sink in, providing support, but also keeping the body more level.
Nectar includes a cooling cover to quickly wick away any moisture so you don’t sleep hot. This layer is followed by a layer of quilted gel memory foam for that plush feeling, followed by layers of gel memory foam, adaptive high core memory foam, and a breathable base layer.
As for value, while the price isn’t exactly the cheapest, the high-quality construction, warranty and trial ought to make up for the cost in the long run.
Price: $850
Highlights:
- Great value
- 180 day in-home trial
- Forever Warranty
Pros:
- Excellent value
- Temperature neutral
Cons:
- Poor edge support
6. Oliver Smith – Organic Cotton – 12 Inch – Deluxe Sleep
If you’re on a budget and want something that is environmentally friendly and has a rich feel, this one’s right up your alley. This Oliver Smith mattress has 100% natural organic cover, non-toxic foam, and is built from Green Foam certified foam.
Going into the category of hybrid mattresses, it uses 15-gauge pocket coils comfortably placed under layers of foam and memory foam, much like the Linenspa mattress we saw earlier. The mattress has a Euro pillow top for added plushness, followed by layers of foam to provide support, comfort, and motion isolation. All these features put together create a great mattress for couples with different preferences.
Price: $399
Highlights:
- Green Foam certified
- 100% natural organic cover
Pros:
- Eco-friendly construction
- Affordable
- Comfortable
- Good bounce and edge support
Cons:
- Has a strong odor that may take several days to go away
- Poor motion isolation
7. Amerisleep AS4 12″ Memory Foam Mattress (Queen)
If you have a restless partner, Amerisleep is exactly what you need. The usual mattress can only do so much against someone who won’t stop tossing and turning through the night. Amerisleep AS4’s generous use of foam and memory foam should help get rid of that problem to a great extent.
Top of the mattress is a 2-inch Bio-Pur memory foam layer, followed by a 4-inch Affinity layer, all on a sag-free support layer. All of this is designed to give the mattress excellent motion isolation, so you sleep soundly even if your partner moves in bed. AS4 has great support for side and combo sleepers, so you don’t have to worry about comfort in different sleep positions for you and your partner.
Price: $1499
Highlights:
- 100 night in-home sleep trial
- 20-year warranty
- One of the best in motion isolation
Pros:
- Excellent motion isolation
- Eco-responsible elements used in construction
- Comfortable
- Great for side sleepers
Cons:
- Low bounce
- Poor edge support
- Risk of sleep-hot problems
Best Mattresses for Couples With Different Preferences – Final Word
It isn’t rare for couples to have different sleep preferences and patterns. Do not decide to be uncomfortable in your sleep, especially when you can easily access some of the best mattresses for couples with different preferences. Keep your individual preferences in mind, take a good look at your budget, and find a mattress where you can truly sleep well together — remember, it’s not just a few hours, sharing a bed is a lifetime decision for a couple.