Innerspring mattresses are the traditional, even conventional mattresses that have been around for decades now. You probably have a good idea of what an innerspring mattress is. They have been a popular choice for decades. Even though foam mattresses have taken the market by storm, innersprings continue to represent a sizeable portion of sales. If you haven’t used an innerspring mattress in years, you may want to take a look. The innerspring mattress has evolved with technology, and offers a lot more. Let’s dive deep to find the best innerspring mattress you can buy.
7 Best Innerspring Mattresses To Look At
1. Saatva Mattress – Best Innerspring Mattress For Back Pain
Saatva Mattress offers a feel of luxury, while being priced to be affordable. This innerspring mattress includes several elements usually found in high-end luxury models, including a coil-on-coil pattern, enhanced lumbar support, and a Euro pillow top for added pressure relief.
One of the most interesting features on the Saatva Mattress is the coil-on-coil system. The mattress has two layers of coils arranged one on top of the other. Lower layer coils are interconnected and give the mattress a deep bounce. The upper layer has pocketed coils that minimize motion transfer. Effectively, the Saatva Mattress retains all the good of the innerspring, and removes several shortcomings.
One of the top buying choices according to several innerspring mattress reviews, Saatva mattress also has an eco-friendly construction. It makes use of recycled steel coils, organic cotton pillowtop, and natural thistle flame retardant. It’s the best innerspring mattress for conventional feel, while embracing modern sleep expectations.
Free Trial: 120 Nights, white-glove delivery
Warranty: 15 Years
| Pros | Cons |
| Modern technology with classic innerspring feel | Lacks the conforming feel for those used to latex or memory foam |
| Free white-glove delivery across contiguous United States | |
| Several size and firmness options available | |
| Great edge support |
2. Signature Sleep Contour Mattress – Best Value Innerspring Mattress
This reversible innerspring mattress offers two firmness options in one package. Don’t like the firmness on your mattress? Just flip it over. To accommodate this feature, coils are located near the center of the mattress, and the top and bottom are padded with foam to get the desired firmness level.
Signature Sleep Contour 8-inch mattress performs very well in innerspring mattress comparisons where value for money is the metric. Sensibly priced, the mattress gets greater value on account of being flippable. Do keep in mind that the mattress works best for low and average weight groups. So if you’re above 200 lbs, this may not be the best mattress for you.
Free Trial: Standard Amazon Policy
Warranty: 10 Years
| Pros | Cons |
| Great value for money | Low trial period |
| Two firmness options in one mattress | Questionable longevity |
3. My Green Mattress Pure Echo – Eco-friendly Innerspring
Just in case the name wasn’t a dead giveaway, yes, sustainability and being environmentally friendly are two biggest selling points of this mattress. My Green Mattress Pure Echo has interesting 3-zone pocketed coil innerspring system. These zones divide the Pure Echo mattress into three equal parts, each individually tasked with providing support to the hips, back, and shoulders.
Different gauge coils are used for each zone, with 14.5 gauge being used for the torso, while the others are 15.5 gauge. To stay in touch with its eco-friendly side, the mattress has its padding made out of organic cotton and all-natural eco-wool. There are no chemical foam retardants or polyfoam in this 11-inch high mattress.
Free Trial: 100 days
Warranty: 10 years
| Pros | Cons |
| Natural, responsibly sourced materials used in construction | Materials may not be suitable for those looking for memory foam style conforming pressure relief |
| Comfortable to sleep on | Many customers say the mattress eventually develops a bad smell |
4. Voila Box Coil-Spring – Intricate Construction Innerspring Mattress
Voila mattress seems very interested to offer you everything, and it shows in the array of layers it has. When you buy an innerspring mattress like the Viola, you also get hold of the comfort of memory foam and latex. While each layer has its purpose, we’ll group similar layers to describe the construction.
Voila Box mattress starts with base foam, followed by pocketed coils sitting covered by layers of transition foam. The comfort layer has a sheet of talalay latex, followed by layers of memory foam. Voila Box has an interesting setup that allows it to have great pressure relief, bounce, and it even manages to sleep temperature neutral. Voila Box Coil-spring mattress is available in several sizes and firmness options, making it quite a fit for most sleep requirements. This mattress has earned its place on our recommendations for innerspring mattresses list not just because of its interesting qualities, but also in terms of the positive innerspring mattress ratings it has received from customers.
Free Trial: 100 Nights
Warranty: 10 Years
| Pros | Cons |
| Though the mattress is a bit expensive, it offers great value in terms of material and construction quality | Can be slightly firmer than advertised |
| Excellent motion isolation | Some off-gassing, that often goes away in a few days |
| Even with layers of memory foam, it is easy to move in bed and there’s great bounce | Some consumers complain that the mattress sleeps hot |
5. Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid – High Comfort And Great Response
Brooklyn Bedding is one of the better known innerspring mattress brands. The Signature Hybrid mattress is surely amongst the best innerspring mattresses you can buy. Brooklyn Signature tries to fix the sleep hot problem of memory foam with its patented cooling technology. They call their memory foam Titan Flex foam. Top two layers of the mattress are memory foam, both infused with TitaniumGel to offer better cooling for the memory foam mattress. Combined with the ventilation offered by the springs, we believe the mattress offers above average cooling, though it may still be a problem for some.
Brooklyn Bedding Signature has 6-inches of individually encased coils that offer great bounce and edge support, while minimizing motion transfer. The high number of coils used and careful setup means that the mattress performs very well for most sleep and weight requirements.
Free Trial: 120 days
Warranty: 10 years
| Pros | Cons |
| TitaniumGel infused memory foam has great response | Some complaints, though rare, of sleeping hot |
| Excellent edge support and motion isolation | |
| A viable option for those who prefer the feel of latex foam, but are allergic |
6. LINENSPA Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid Mattress – Popular Budget Innerspring
Linenspa innerspring mattress is an excellent choice for those who would like to upgrade their old innerspring, but are on a tight budget. Available in almost all standard shapes, the Linenspa innerspring is available in the height options of 8, 10, and 12 inch. While the 12-inch includes pocketed coils, the other options rely on the classic innerspring.
Yep, that means there is going to be a definite motion transfer, although that will be attenuated to some degree by the presence of the memory foam comfort layer. Even though it is a simple option, the 8-inch, firm rated mattress can be very helpful, if not the best innerspring mattress for back pain. The memory foam will handle the contouring and pressure relief, while the innerspring setup will make it easier for you to move in bed, or get on/off your mattress.
Free Trial: Amazon standard policy
Warranty: 10 years
| Pros | Cons |
| Excellent price point and value for money | Unclear rules on free trial |
| Available in several sizes, firmness, and height options also available | Relatively high motion transfer for 8 and 10-inch mattresses |
7. Classic Brands Serena Pillow Top Innerspring – Modern Innerspring With Classic Feel
Classic Brands Serena makes our list of best innerspring mattresses for its very authentic innerspring mattress feel, but with a clear upgrade that addresses conventional downsides of the mattresses. Individually packed steel coils give the Classic Brands Serena a system of excellent support, while also minimizing any troubles that may come its way due to motion transfer.
The coils are topped by a comfort foam layer that gives you a soft, comfortable feel. Serena also has a quilted knit pillowtop cover that adds an extra layer of comfort to the mattress. By virtue of following the classic innerspring mattress, and minimizing its flaws, the 10-inch high Classic Brands Serena has performed very well with innerspring mattress ratings.
Free Trial: Amazon standard returns policy
Warranty: 10 Years
| Pros | Cons |
| Great bounce and edge support | Some customers have complaints about unclear warranty |
| Low motion transfer |
How To Choose The Best Innerspring Mattress
Types Of Coils For Innerspring Mattresses
Four main types of coils are available for use with innerspring mattresses:
Pocket Spring (Wrapped Coils)
Known by different names including pocket, encased, wrapped, or Marshall coil, this is often considered the best type of coil. Each coil is placed within its own fabric pocket and remains unattached to the other. The highlight is even weight distribution and greater motion isolation. These coils are usually the most expensive.
Bonnell Coils
Also called Open Coils, these are the most commonly used coils in innerspring mattresses. The design includes multiple springs that are interconnected with a wire frame. Usually found in cheaper mattresses, they provide very firm support.
Continuous Coils
In this design, a single wire goes uninterrupted through the length and width of the mattress.These are then attached to helical wires, forming the full system. Though durable, these mattresses are very firm and noisy.
Offset Coils
Offset coils are quite similar to Bonnell Coils, but with a helical wire on top of each spring. Its qualities are quite similar to pocket coil, and offers greater body contouring and motion isolation in comparison to Bonnell Coil innerspring mattresses.
Understanding Coil Counts And Gauges
Before you zone in on your choice of best innerspring mattress for you, take a look at its coil count and gauges. Coil count, as its name implies, is the number of coils/springs inside a mattress. A larger number of coils generally indicates a better quality mattress, and by extension, a more expensive mattress as well.
Gauges define thickness of the metal wire used, and usually ranges from 12-15 for innerspring mattress. These numbers are not universal though, and you can expect to find mattresses that go well beyond this range. Keep in mind, higher gauge number implies lower thickness of the wire. A higher gauge will give you a softer mattress. For example, a 15 gauge mattress will be super soft, while 12 gauge will be very firm.
Innerspring Mattress Lifespan And Value For Money
Innerspring mattresses are available in a wide price range, going from fairly cheap mattresses in the $100-$200 range, to far more expensive ones that could easily touch $4000-$5000. On an average, innerspring mattresses have the lowest lifespan amongst all mattress types, generally lasting lower than 6 years. However, given the comparatively lower prices, innersprings can still be a great deal. A careful choice could yet give you the best innerspring mattress you can easily afford.
Lifespan of your innerspring mattress also depends on coil gauge and construction quality/materials. Usually, lower gauge coils built out of tempered stainless steel last the longest. Since pocketed springs cannot be made from this material, they are often have the least lifespan. Bonnell and offset coils usually have the longest lifespan.
Pros And Cons of Innerspring Mattresses
| Pros | Cons |
| Usually the most affordable mattress | Springs and coils can be noisy, leading to the mattress making creaking sounds |
| Bouncier and more responsive than other mattress types | With the exception of pocketed coils, most innerspring mattresses have high motion transfer |
| Better ventilation means the mattresses sleep temperature neutral | The average innerspring mattress provides poorer contouring and pressure relief compared to memory foam and latex foam. This means they have below average pain and pressure relief |
Best Innerspring Mattress — Concluding Remarks
Your search for the best innerspring mattress can go through quite a few choices, given the sheer variety of innersprings available. Thankfully, you’ve got information at your fingertips that will make it easier to find the best innerspring mattress 2018. Hopefully, this information will also help you determine if the mattress provides you value for money, and fits your specific requirements. Take a look at our curated selection above, or use the information provided to dive deeper into finding your choice of the best innerspring mattress.